Sergei Eisenstein on ‘Battleship Potemkin’
Every phenomenon has a chance, superficial manifestation. And underlying it is a profound feeling that reason has dictated it. So it was too with the film Battleship Potemkin. A grand epic, ‘1905’, was conceived by Nina Agadjanova and myself in preparation for the 20th anniversary of 1905. The mutiny on the battleship Potemkin was to have been just one among the many episodes chosen to commemorate that year of the revolutionary struggle.
The ‘chance events’ began. The preparatory work of the Anniversary Commission dragged on. Finally there were complications with filming the picture as a whole. August came, and the anniversary was due in December. There was only one thing for it: to choose one episode from the whole epic to encapsulate the integral sense, the feel of that remarkable year.
Another fleeting chance. In September you can film outdoors only in Odessa and Sebastopol. The mutiny on the Potemkin was played out in Odessa and Sebastopol. But then came something preordained: the episode of the mutiny, an episode which Vladimir llyich [Lenin] had earlier singled out for special attention, was also one of the most representative episodes of the whole year. It is curious to recall now that this historical episode had been more or less forgotten … The Potemkin mutiny had somehow been erased from memory … So it was all the more important to resurrect it, to focus attention upon it, to remind people of this moment which embodied so many instructive elements of the technique of revolutionary uprising, typical of the period of a ‘dress rehearsal for October’.
Sergei Eisenstein in Richard Taylor (ed.), Eisenstein Writings 1934-1947 (translated by William Powell, BFI Publishing, 1996) Reprinted in Sight and Sound, September 2002
The structure of Potemkin is that of the classic five-act tragedy, the Stairs sequence approximating act four. At its most obvious level, the film has been regarded (and censored) as propaganda for Revolution. At a deeper level it was a complex work of art which its director believed would affect all who saw it. As he later explained: ‘Our psychological approach is on the one hand that of the great Russian scholar, Pavlov, with his principles of reflexology, and on the other, that of the Austrian Freud – the principles of psychoanalysis.’
The two theories that dominated Eisenstein’s work up to the condemnation of Bezhin Meadow in 1937, are powerfully demonstrated in Potemkin. Of equal importance there is ‘typage’ and ‘montage’ (editing). His initial idea of ‘typage’ sprang from Italian Commedia dell’Arte as shown primitively, according to him, in Strike. For Potemkin he discarded professional actors except for Grigori Alexandrov. He replaced actors with ‘people off the streets’ who impressed him as embodying the greatest number of characteristics of the ‘types’ he envisaged. He found the perfect image of the ship’s doctor in a man he saw shovelling coal in a Sevastopol hotel, while the Priest was mostly closely approximated by a gardener who had never acted in his life.
Prior to Eisenstein, numerous directors had made attempts at ‘montage’, probably most notably D.W. Griffith. But Eisentein’s ideas were more complex and constituted the essence of his cinematic methods. Had the rushes of Potemkin been hung up in an editing room they would have made no sense to an editor. The editing pattern only evolved when Eisenstein sat with his splicer and began to work. His ideas of ‘montage’ had received stimulus from beyond cinematography. A vital influence had come from his knowledge of hieroglyphs for writing the Chinese language (traced back from his having learned 300 Japanese characters). Two simplified, unrelated images when united correspond to a concept – i.e. the ideogram ‘to weep’ is an eye and water. A simple example of Eisentein’s adaptation is the shot of the Cossack with raised sword followed by the shot of the spectacled woman whose eye streams blood. It is the spectator who jumps to the idea that the Cossack has struck the woman.
Eisenstein’s use of close-ups to produce ‘shocking’ emotional effects was influenced by his study of the enlarged faces in Japanese prints, particularly Sharaku’s actor prints. (Throughout his films and writings he was finding and adapting the ‘cinematic’ elements in other arts.)
Because the equipment available to Eisenstein and [director of photography] Eduard Tisse was old and primitive in comparison to that in Hollywood and elsewhere, they were compelled to experiment on a hit and miss basis. For the sequence of ‘fog over the harbour’, they had no idea if any of their shots would be visible, it being unheard of to shoot in such early morning misty light.
Their risky experiments paid off. They used mirror reflectors for the first time in Russia, and Tisse devised out-of-focus photography. For mass scenes Tisse used a change in lens instead of a change in camera set-ups. For the Stairs sequence they built a moveable wagonette sufficiently large to hold the cameras. This was shuttled up and down alongside the steps on specially constructed wooden rails.
A description of the stairs shooting by Eisenstein’s colleague and lifelong friend, Maxim Shtraukh, evokes the work: ‘In the period of one week, people in panic, pushing and trampling each other, ran down and rolled down the stairway in order; on the signal of the director ‘stop’, to stop and again go up and begin the panic, the pushing … Above they were squeezed by the measured steps of the soldiers’ boots and below by the mounted Cossacks cutting into the people. This canvas of fabulous slaughter at the will of the director again brought to light the reality of the past as in a nightmare.’ Many of the characters and extras were people who had been present and survived the real events in Odessa in 1905.
Later in analysing the sequence, Eisenstein noted ‘the rhythmic drum of the soldiers’ feet as they descended the steps violates all metrical demands. Unsynchronised with the beat of the cutting, this drumming comes in off-beat, and the shot itself is entirely different in its solution with each of these appearances. The final pull of tension is supplied by the transfer of the descending feet to another rhythm – a new kind of downward movement – the next intensity level of the same activity – the baby-carriage rolling down the steps …’ Silent as the film was, Eisenstein conceived it in sound in many places. With its success in Berlin he planned with Edmund Meisel, the German composer, a special score. They worked in the same manner as contemporary collaborators on sound tracks.
Eisenstein never saw Odessa or the steps again for nine years. In 1934 when he did, he stared down the steps contemptuously, unable to recapture his ‘creative ecstasy’ of 1925. He flung out incoherent remarks and fled. Next morning he was drawn back when he spat grape pips and obscenities down the steps, declaring unconvincingly that the inspiration for the stairs sequence was only the chase denouement of ‘the Western’, a statement contradicted by the reams he wrote about Potemkin.
National Film Theatre programme notes
BATTLESHIP POTEMKIN (BRONENOSETS POTEMKIN)
Director: Sergei M. Eisenstein
Co-director: Grigori V. Aleksandrov
Production: First Studio Goskino
Production Manager: Yakov Bliokh
Assistant Directors: Maksim Straukh, Mikhail S. Gomorov, Aleksandr I. Levchin, Aleksandr Antonov
Screenplay: Sergei M. Eisenstein
From the screenplay for 1905 God by: Nina Agadjanova, Sergei M. Eisenstein
Director of Photography: Eduard Tisse
Assistant Photographer: Vladimir Popov
Editor: Sergei M. Eisenstein
Art Director: Vasili Rakhals
Intertitles: Nikolai Asseyev, S.M. Tretiakov
Cast
Aleksandr Antonov (Vakulinchuk, sailor)
Vladimir Barsky (Captain Golikov)
Grigori V. Aleksandrov (Lieutenant Guiliarovsky)
Mikhail S. Gomorov (Matushenko, sailor)
Aleksandr I. Levchin (petty officer)
Marussov (officer)
I. Bobrov (conscript)
Julia Eisenstein (woman with pig)
Beatrice Vitoldi (woman with pram)
A. Glauberman (Aba, boy killed on steps)
Propkopenko (Aba’s mother)
Korobei (sailor with no legs)
N. Poltavtseva (teacher with pince-nez)
Zerenin (student)
Konstantin Feldman (himself, Odessa revolutionary)
Glotov (anti-Semitic provocateur)
Repnikova (woman on steps)
Maksim Straukh
Andrei Fait
USSR 1925
72 mins
Digital
With Edmund Meisel score
ART OF ACTION: CELEBRATING THE REAL ACTION STARS OF CINEMA
Big Screen Classics: The History of Action
Safety Last! + One Week
Mon 21 Oct 14:30; Tue 5 Nov 20:30; Sat 30 Nov
Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior
Mon 21 Oct 18:20; Wed 27 Nov 20:50
Seven Samurai Shichinin no samurai
Mon 21 Oct 18:30; Sun 3 Nov 13:30; Sun 10 Nov 11:45; Sun 24 Nov 14:30
Hell Drivers
Tue 22 Oct 18:15; Thu 14 Nov 12:20; Sat 16 Nov 20:40
The Thief of Bagdad
Wed 23 Oct 14:30; Thu 31 Oct 12:20; Sat 9 Nov 12:30
Goldfinger 60th anniversary screenings
Wed 23 Oct 18:20 (+ intro by season programmer Dick Fiddy); Sun 10 Nov 18:40; Sat 23 Nov 18:20
Bullitt
Wed 23 Oct 20:40; Sun 3 Nov 16:25; Thu 21 Nov 14:30; Tue 26 Nov 20:45
The Mark of Zorro
Thu 24 Oct 14:30 (+ intro by Bryony Dixon, curator, BFI National Archive); Sat 2 Nov 11:45; Sat 23 Nov 15:00
Enter the Dragon
Thu 24 Oct 20:45; Fri 1 Nov 14:40; Mon 4 Nov 20:50; Wed 13 Nov 18:10 (+ intro by film critic Katie Smith-Wong); Mon 18 Nov 14:30
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon Wo hu cang long
Fri 25 Oct 20:35; Sun 3 Nov 11:00 BFI IMAX; Fri 8 Nov 12:20; Mon 11 Nov 18:00; Wed 27 Nov 18:10 (+ intro)
Battleship Potemkin Bronenosets Potyomkin
Sat 26 Oct 13:20; Thu 7 Nov 20:55; Tue 12 Nov 14:30
Captain Blood
Sun 27 Oct 12:45; Wed 6 Nov 18:10 (+ intro)
The Train
Sun 27 Oct 17:45; Sat 2 Nov 20:25
Taxi
Mon 28 Oct 18:30; Fri 22 Nov 18:20; Mon 25 Nov 20:50
Three the Hard Way
Wed 30 Oct 18:15 (+ intro by Ti Singh, BFI FAN season producer); Thu 7 Nov 12:30; Sun 17 Nov 16:10
Police Story Ging chaat goo si
Fri 15 Nov 18:00 (+ panel discussion with Action Xtreme); Tue 19 Nov 20:55; Thu 28 Nov 18:20
District B13 Banlieue 13
Wed 20 Nov 18:20 (+ intro by Chee Keong Cheung, writer, director, producer and CEO of Action Xtreme); Fri 29 Nov 20:45
ART OF ACTION: CELEBRATING THE REAL ACTION STARS OF CINEMA
Big Screen Classics: The History of Action
Safety Last! + One Week
Mon 21 Oct 14:30; Tue 5 Nov 20:30; Sat 30 Nov
Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior
Mon 21 Oct 18:20; Wed 27 Nov 20:50
Seven Samurai Shichinin no samurai
Mon 21 Oct 18:30; Sun 3 Nov 13:30; Sun 10 Nov 11:45; Sun 24 Nov 14:30
Hell Drivers
Tue 22 Oct 18:15; Thu 14 Nov 12:20; Sat 16 Nov 20:40
The Thief of Bagdad
Wed 23 Oct 14:30; Thu 31 Oct 12:20; Sat 9 Nov 12:30
Goldfinger 60th anniversary screenings
Wed 23 Oct 18:20 (+ intro by season programmer Dick Fiddy); Sun 10 Nov 18:40; Sat 23 Nov 18:20
Bullitt
Wed 23 Oct 20:40; Sun 3 Nov 16:25; Thu 21 Nov 14:30; Tue 26 Nov 20:45
The Mark of Zorro
Thu 24 Oct 14:30 (+ intro by Bryony Dixon, curator, BFI National Archive); Sat 2 Nov 11:45; Sat 23 Nov 15:00
Enter the Dragon
Thu 24 Oct 20:45; Fri 1 Nov 14:40; Mon 4 Nov 20:50; Wed 13 Nov 18:10 (+ intro by film critic Katie Smith-Wong); Mon 18 Nov 14:30
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
Wo hu cang long Fri 25 Oct 20:35; Sun 3 Nov 11:00 BFI IMAX; Fri 8 Nov 12:20; Mon 11 Nov 18:00; Wed 27 Nov 18:10 (+ intro)
Battleship Potemkin Bronenosets Potyomkin
Sat 26 Oct 13:20; Thu 7 Nov 20:55; Tue 12 Nov 14:30
Captain Blood
Sun 27 Oct 12:45; Wed 6 Nov 18:10 (+ intro)
The Train
Sun 27 Oct 17:45; Sat 2 Nov 20:25
Taxi
Mon 28 Oct 18:30; Fri 22 Nov 18:20; Mon 25 Nov 20:50
Three the Hard Way
Wed 30 Oct 18:15 (+ intro by Ti Singh, BFI FAN season producer); Thu 7 Nov 12:30; Sun 17 Nov 16:10
Police Story Ging chaat goo si
Fri 15 Nov 18:00 (+ panel discussion with Action Xtreme); Tue 19 Nov 20:55; Thu 28 Nov 18:20
District B13 Banlieue 13
Wed 20 Nov 18:20 (+ intro by Chee Keong Cheung, writer, director, producer and CEO of Action Xtreme); Fri 29 Nov 20:45
With thanks to
A BFI FAN initiative supported through National Lottery
SIGHT AND SOUND
Never miss an issue with Sight and Sound, the BFI’s internationally renowned film magazine. Subscribe from just £25*
*Price based on a 6-month print subscription (UK only). More info: sightandsoundsubs.bfi.org.uk
BFI SOUTHBANK
Welcome to the home of great film and TV, with three cinemas and a studio, a world-class library, regular exhibitions and a pioneering Mediatheque with 1000s of free titles for you to explore. Browse special-edition merchandise in the BFI Shop.We're also pleased to offer you a unique new space, the BFI Riverfront – with unrivalled riverside views of Waterloo Bridge and beyond, a delicious seasonal menu, plus a stylish balcony bar for cocktails or special events. Come and enjoy a pre-cinema dinner or a drink on the balcony as the sun goes down.
BECOME A BFI MEMBER
Enjoy a great package of film benefits including priority booking at BFI Southbank and BFI Festivals. Join today at bfi.org.uk/join
BFI PLAYER
We are always open online on BFI Player where you can watch the best new, cult & classic cinema on demand. Showcasing hand-picked landmark British and independent titles, films are available to watch in three distinct ways: Subscription, Rentals & Free to view.
See something different today on player.bfi.org.uk
Join the BFI mailing list for regular programme updates. Not yet registered? Create a new account at www.bfi.org.uk/signup
Programme notes and credits compiled by Sight and Sound and the BFI Documentation Unit
Notes may be edited or abridged
Questions/comments? Contact the Programme Notes team by email