SPOILER WARNING The following notes give away some of the plot.
Near the conclusion of Big Wednesday, an awed young surfer stares out at a fearsome swell – waves like crumbling tower blocks. ‘It’s outrageous,’ he says. Next to him, Bear (Sam Melville), the old timer guru, sets him straight. ‘That’s just the lemon next to the pie. It’s nothing, it’s going to get bigger.’ These words have entered into surfing folklore, words to be rolled around the tongue and savoured as a communal mantra.
The first time we heard them outside of Big Wednesday was on a beach in deepest Cornwall, while taking a crash course in the art of surfing as preparation for writing our film, Blue Juice. It didn’t matter that we were wearing chafing wet suits, apparently salvaged from a World War Two diving mission, that our cumbersome boards had all the glamour of a Morris Marina, or even that the surf was barely two feet high. The young surf instructor simply wanted to hear the words, to get the call and response answer from his colleague. That was when we realised that Big Wednesday was more than a portrayal of the surfing culture: it had become part of it.
So what is it about this tale of the golden youth of California that can so affect their pale brethren across the Atlantic so long after its original 1978 release? For a start it is unashamedly epic in scale and heroic in tone. Constructed almost as a modem-day Greek legend, its voiceover immediately delights in introducing us not only to its young heroes but also to a quasi-mythical world in which nature has a godlike power. We could be setting sail with the Argonauts, but instead we are in early 60s California: the young surfers, with their statuesque physiques, enter their arena, the beach, through crumbling temple-like columns.
The score is shamelessly epic, all military brass and kettledrums, sweeping crescendos and pounding new Wagnerian overtures. It’s easy to see the connection between director John Milius’ contribution here and to his work as scriptwriter of Apocalypse Now – the helicopter attack set to Ride of the Valkyries that leads to Robert Duvall’s line, ‘Charlie don’t surf.’ There is also the classic image in the title sequence, the same as that used on the original poster. A man stands on the foreshore clutching an upright board that must reach 16 feet into the sky. The camera pulls back to reveal the waves he faces: waves that dwarf the massive board and leave us to wonder at the foolhardy courage it takes to ride those turbulent waters.
It’s a tale of male bonding and camaraderie. The idea that ‘there’s nothing more important than your friends’ runs like a spine through the film. The female characters remain peripheral to the action, waiting on the sideline as the ‘battles’ are fought. The young men, Jack Barlow (William Katt), Matt Johnson (Jan-Michael Vincent) and Leroy ‘The Masochist’ Smith (Gary Busey) learn lessons from the ‘wise man’, Bear, as they progress towards manhood. They move towards their inevitable date with destiny, the big day that Bear prophesies will come, when the three friends will be able to ‘distinguish themselves’.
While the film’s central concerns (and what still endears it to the worldwide wave-riding community) may be what it takes to be a man – and a heroic surfer man at that – Big Wednesday does not ignore the world outside beach culture. Since the film covers a turbulent decade in American history, the characters’ lives are inevitably affected. But it clings to the idea of the constancy of the unchanging waves at its core. Almost from the beginning, the outside world is portrayed as a dangerous place where the certainties of the ocean no longer apply.
When gatecrashers invade a surfers’ party, the violence that ensues is almost comic book in nature. Despite the flurry of blows, you never believe that anyone is actually hurt. This contrasts starkly with the next sequence, when the three friends head off down Mexico way and start a barroom brawl that explodes into real and fatal violence.
Inevitably, Vietnam, the defining event for the protagonists’ generation, intrudes upon their lives. There is a very funny sequence where the surfers attempt to avoid the draft, but there is also a sense of foreboding as the straight-laced Jack volunteers, and their wastrel friend Waxer is called up. The world outside the beach has taken two of their number and Waxer is never to return.
Matt Johnson becomes a pitiable drunk. Bear succumbs to the ‘American dream’, his board-making shack transformed into a corporate high street venture. The certainty and simplicity of the waves are forgotten for a time and there can be no happiness without them. The voiceover tells us, ‘But now it all seemed behind us. The change wasn’t in the beach, or the rocks, or the waves. It was in the people.’
Eventually, of course, it does all come back to the sea. The prophesied epic swell comes and when Matt walks through those crumbling columns onto the beach, his two boyhood friends are waiting to ‘draw the line’ with him. The final surfing sequence remains the touchstone that all other surfing movies are measured against. The waves are literal monsters: monsters the three friends must meet to assert their manhood. And here is the core idea that explains Big Wednesday’s continued appeal to the very community it portrays, the spine-tingling knowledge that one day there may come a wave that will prove the ultimate test. It not only explains their lifestyle, but validates it.
As one surfing merchandising slogan boasts, ‘only a surfer knows the feeling.’ But this film can take you into the sub-culture, help you understand the joy found in uncertain harmony with nature and even inspire you to plunge into the cold Atlantic, in the thrilling search for your first unsteady upright ride.
But handle it carefully. Big Wednesday has found its way into a lot of people’s blood, even changing lives. How many movies can claim that? I know of at least one ex-London cabbie who never came back, who now sits peering out to sea, mouthing the mantra: ‘That’s just the lemon next to the pie.’
Peter Salmi and Carl Prechezer, Sight and Sound, November 1996
Director: John Milius
©/Production Company: Warner Bros.
Production Company: A-Team Productions
Executive Producers: Alex Rose, Tamara Asseyev
Producer: Buzz Feitshans
Surfing Sequence Producer: Greg MacGillivray
Unit Production Manager: John G. Wilson
Water Unit Liaison: Fred Hemmings
Land 2nd Unit Director: Terry J. Leonard
Assistant Director: Richard Hashimoto
2nd Assistant Directors: Bill Scott, Victor Hsu, Carol Jackson
Casting: Karen Grossman
Screenplay: John Milius, Dennis Aaberg
Director of Photography: Bruce Surtees
Photography (Surfing Sequences): Greg MacGillivray
Photography (Special Water Unit):
George Greenough, Dan Merkel
Surfing Photography Consultants: Spyder Wills, Roger Brown, Bud Browne
Camera Operators: Garrett Graham, Tom Del Ruth
Camera Assistant: Brad May
Key Grip: Ken Adams
Stills Photography: Gemma La Mana
Wipeouts: Bruce Raymond
Matte Artist: P.S. Ellenshaw
Special Effects: Joe Unsinn
Editor: Robert L. Wolfe
Also Edited by: Tim O’Meara
Production Designer: Charles Rosen
Art Director: Dean Mitzner
Set Decorator: Ira Bates
Women’s Wardrobe: Ann Lambert
Men’s Wardrobe: Bill Milton Jr.
Make-up: Jack Young
Main Title Design: Rocklen/Metter Productions
Opticals: Pacific Title
Music: Basil Poledouris
Guitarists: Keola Beamer, Kapono Beamer
Orchestrations: Greig McRitchie
Sound Recording: Harlan Riggs
Additional Sound Editor: Ross Taylor
Sound Effects Editors: Joe von Stroheim, Marvin I. Kosberg
Surfing Masters: Ian Cairns, Peter Townend, Bill Hamilton, Gerry Lopez, J. Riddle, Jackie Dunn
Jan-Michael Vincent (Matt Johnson)
William Katt (Jack Barlow)
Gary Busey (Leroy ‘The Masochist’ Smith)
Patti D’Arbanville (Sally Johnson)
Lee Purcell (Peggy Gordon)
Darrell Fetty (Jim ‘Waxer’ King)
Sam Melville (‘The Bear’)
Gerry Lopez (himself)
Hank Warden (‘Shopping Cart’)
Joe Spinell (psychologist)
Steve Kanaly (Sally’s husband)
Barbara Hale (Mrs Barlow)
Fran Ryan (Lucy)
Dennis Aaberg (‘Slick’)
Reb Brown (‘Enforcer’)
Robert Englund (‘Fly’)
Keith Davis (‘Ostrich’)
Johnny Fain (‘Breathman’)
Richard Dano (‘Panhead’)
Michael Talbott (‘Hog’)
Geoff Parks (‘Crusher’)
Ivar Arai (‘Boogie’)
Titus Napoleon (‘Chubby’)
Frank McRae (sergeant)
Perry Lang (tall kid)
Mike Raden (Denny)
Pat Beckwith (Flea)
Kathy McCullen, Charlene Tilton, Terry Bolo, Kevan Dignam, Sherry Lee Marks, Cindy Daly, Lynn Theel, Janet Johnson (party girls)
Lorie Busk (Melissa as a child)
Jack Bernardi (tailor)
Gray Frederickson (doctor)
Arthur Rosenberg (official)
Stephen Mendillo (orderly)
Aesop Aquarian (hippy)
Guy Larry Finley, Richard O’Bryan,
Todd Lookinland, Gary Boyle, Sasha Jensen, Kevin Schultz (surfers)
Christopher Woods (lifeguard)
Jimmy Bracken (kid surfer)
Stacy Keach Sr (old man)
Iris Korn (old woman)
Ollie O’Toole (minister)
Celia Kaye (The Bear’s bride)
Keola Beamer, Kapono Beamer (slack-key guitarists)
Brain Damage Vincent (Matt’s dog)
Clete Roberts * Herb Voland * John Milius *
A BFI National Archive print
Welcome to the home of great film and TV, with three cinemas and a studio, a world-class library, regular exhibitions and a pioneering Mediatheque with 1000s of free titles for you to explore. Browse special-edition merchandise in the BFI Shop.We're also pleased to offer you a unique new space, the BFI Riverfront – with unrivalled riverside views of Waterloo Bridge and beyond, a delicious seasonal menu, plus a stylish balcony bar for cocktails or special events. Come and enjoy a pre-cinema dinner or a drink on the balcony as the sun goes down.
BECOME A BFI MEMBER
Enjoy a great package of film benefits including priority booking at BFI Southbank and BFI Festivals. Join today at bfi.org.uk/join
We are always open online on BFI Player where you can watch the best new, cult & classic cinema on demand. Showcasing hand-picked landmark British and independent titles, films are available to watch in three distinct ways: Subscription, Rentals & Free to view.
See something different today on player.bfi.org.uk
Join the BFI mailing list for regular programme updates. Not yet registered? Create a new account at www.bfi.org.uk/signup
Programme notes and credits compiled by the BFI Documentation Unit
Notes may be edited or abridged
Questions/comments? Contact the Programme Notes team by email