SPOILER WARNING The following notes give away some of the plot.
A contemporary review
Scorsese’s return to the milieu of Mean Streets invites comparison less with that film than with Coppola’s The Godfather. Where Mean Streets was concerned primarily with questions of environment and ethics, GoodFellas, like The Godfather, analyses the patterns of power. But while The Godfather tried to blueprint the pyramid systematically erected out of carefully sculptured blocks of honour and respect, GoodFellas sets out to explore the profit motive that makes those qualities so eminently desirable. As Scorsese puts it, explaining what attracted him to Nicholas Pileggi’s book Wiseguy (a slice of factual reportage), ‘What people don’t understand is that a gangster’s job is not to go around killing people. A gangster’s job is to make money’.
GoodFellas (if you exclude a minatory precredits sequence anticipating a later killing) therefore starts in exemplary Horatio Alger fashion, with young Henry Hill contemplating the world of gangsterdom spread out across the street from his front doorstep and finding it good: ‘To me’, his off-screen narration explains, ‘being a gangster was even better than being President of the United States’. What we see is an unprepossessing tableau of over-fed, over-dressed but none too hygienic-looking hoods cluttering the sidewalks with their arrogance and loudmouthed bonhomie; what he sees is an intoxicating display of ‘wealth, power and girth – people with money to burn, the right to park on fire hydrants without reprisal, the respect that comes from being feared and having an organisation as back-up. Taking his first timid steps in this world and finding the ground solid underfoot, the young Henry Hill is quoted by Pileggi as delightedly discovering that he has come up out of nowhere into a world of wish-fulfilment: ‘I was part of something. I belonged. I was treated like I was a grown-up. I was living a fantasy’.
The fantasy, of course, has its tendencies towards nightmare, as the pre-credits sequence intimates with a scene in which Henry, after helping Jimmy Conway and Tommy DeVito to dispose of the body of Billy Batts by stowing it in the boot of their car, watches with aversion but unprotesting as-muffled knocking from the boot indicating that there is yet life in the victim – his companions stop the car and enthusiastically finish the job with carving-knife and gun. Throughout, Henry’s distaste for bloodshed is carefully noted: as with the murder of Billy Batts, he is the only person present to show concern when Tommy DeVito summarily guns down a kid (Henry’s successor, as it were) he judges to have insulted him. His reaction is not a moral or a squeamish one, however: just after witnessing his first gangland shooting, told off for wasting towels when he tries to stop the victim from bleeding to death, Henry cheerily remarks (in his off-screen commentary), ‘It was a glorious time’. Rather, it is a pragmatic recognition of the fact that killing is unnecessary, attracts unwelcome attention, and interferes with the serious business of making money.
The real nightmare lying in wait for Henry is that, while obediently obeying the laws of the system, he is simultaneously led to a betrayal of and by that system. Stage one is that, being Irish like Jimmy (despite his Sicilian mother), Henry can never be a ‘made’ man. Henry is content with this, but gets caught in the crossfire when Tommy DeVito, having killed a ‘made’ man, is ceremonially set up for execution on the pretext that he himself is to be ‘made’, thus sending the already unbalanced Jimmy over the edge (partly from personal grief over Tommy, partly from disappointed expectation of having a ‘made’ friend as a close connection). Stage two is that, by the rules of the milieu, dependents are entitled to help and consideration only while their provider is on the street, so that the jailed Henry has no choice but to sell drugs to support his wife and children while they are ‘on their own’. Caught between personal loyalties and a system that adds up to dog eat dog unless a bigger dog says no, Henry is to all intents and purposes a dead man.
The essential difference between GoodFellas and The Godfather, in fact, is the angle from which the Mafia organisation is viewed. Where The Godfather examined the pyramid of power from the viewpoint of the pharaohs for whom it is intended, GoodFellas is down with the slaves who tote the bricks, picking up their own lavish rewards while they are so doing. With the exception of the largely benign Paulie Cicero (who may or may not set Henry up for the kill at the end), the Mafia bosses are confined here to noises off, and it is the rank-and-file who have to try to reconcile their impulses (good or bad) with the rules laid down for their social survival. The result is undoubtedly the most realistic appraisal to date of organised crime and how it operates. As Ron Hubbard slyly implies in a throwaway joke in his ten-volume s-f epic Mission Earth – its neo-Mafia boss lady, Babe Corleone, is the widow of none other than ‘Holy Joe’ – The Godfather discredits its analysis of Mafia structures by wallowing in nostalgia, sentimentality and heroworship.
Unconcerned with making excuses or moral judgments (‘After a while’, says Karen, echoing the film’s tone, ‘it didn’t seem like crime, more like Henry was enterprising’ ), GoodFellas sagely keeps its distance throughout, letting appearances speak for themselves: Paulie Cicero’s godfather is strictly a nothing man; the wedding sequence (same ingredients as in The Godfather, but minus the nostalgic grandeur) emerges as tackily commonplace; the long tracking shot accompanying Henry and Karen as he shows her how ‘in’ he is by taking her into the Copacabana Club through the interminable kitchens and back regions, in fact suggests that his grand entrance is more like a backdoor skulk; and Henry, proudly showing off the splendiferous new apartment in which he has set up his mistress, unveils a monument to ignorance and grotesque bad taste. As a hero, Henry similarly flatters to deceive throughout; handsome, personable, apparently endowed with sensibility and sensitivity, he learns not a thing, is changed not one iota by his experiences, finally disappearing into the Witness Protection Program as though leaving the best of all possible worlds (‘I still love the “life”’).
Superbly shot on location, with uniformly fine performances and Scorsese’s direction at its most sinuously muscular, GoodFellas disappoints only in the slightly perfunctory use of Henry’s wife as a second narrator (her comments offer stronger counterpoint in Pileggi’s original) and in the necessary truncation of the book. A remarkably faithful transcription, the adaptation (by Scorsese and Pileggi himself) nevertheless has to skimp in a crucial area, cutting down on the painstakingly detailed descriptions of the ins and outs of the incredible proliferation of organised scams which made Henry Hill and his self-styled fellow wiseguys (why was the title changed?) feel that America was like a neighbourhood department store where they enjoyed unlimited charge accounts. These reservations are minor, though, in a fascinating, intelligent, and in some ways groundbreaking movie.
Tom Milne, Monthly Film Bulletin, December 1990
GOODFELLAS
Directed by: Martin Scorsese
©: Warner Bros Inc.
An Irwin Winkler production
Presented by: Warner Bros.
Executive Producer: Barbara De Fina
Produced by: Irwin Winkler
Associate Producer: Bruce Pustin
Production Associates: Michele Giordano, Janet Crosby
Unit Production Manager: Bruce Pustin
Production Accountant: Todd Arnow
Location Managers: Steve Rose, Amy Herman, Neri Tannenbaum, Daniel Coss
2nd Unit Director: Joseph Reidy
1st Assistant Director: Joseph Reidy
Script Supervisor: Sheila Paige
Casting by: Ellen Lewis, Laura Rosenthal
Screenplay by: Nicholas Pileggi, Martin Scorsese
Based on the book Wiseguy by: Nicholas Pileggi
Directors of Photography: Michael Ballhaus, Barry Sonnenfeld
Camera Operator: David Dunlap
1st Assistant Camera: Florian Ballhaus
Still Photographer: Barry Wetcher
Special Effects: Conrad Brink Sr
Film Editor: Thelma Schoonmaker
Editor: James Kwei
Production Designer: Kristi Zea
Art Director: Maher Ahmad
Set Decorator: Les Bloom
Set Dressers: Bruce Swanson, Susan Pileggi
Costume Designer: Richard Bruno
Make-up Artists: Allen Weisinger, Carl Fullerton, Ilona Herman
Hairstylists: Bill Farley, Alan D’Angerio
Titles by: Saul Bass, Elaine Bass
Opticals: R/Greenberg Associates, Arriflex Cameras, Technicolor
Music Editor: Christopher Brooks
Production Sound Mixers: James Sabat, Frank Graziadei
Boom Operator: Louis Sabat
Re-recording Mixer: Tom Fleischman
Supervising Sound Editor: Skip Lievsay
Supervising Dialogue Editors: Philip Stockton, Marissa Littlefield, Fred Rosenberg, Jeff Stern, Bruce Kitzmeyer
ADR Editor: Gail Showalter
Supervising Foley Editor: Ron Bochar
Foley Editors: Bruce Pross, Frank Kern
Stunt Co-ordinator: Michael Russo
Cast
Robert De Niro (James Conway)
Ray Liotta (Henry Hill)
Joe Pesci (Tommy DeVito)
Lorraine Bracco (Karen Hill)
Paul Sorvino (Paul Cicero)
Frank Sivero (Frank Carbone)
Tony Darrow (Sonny Bunz)
Mike Starr (Frenchy)
Frank Vincent (Billy Batts)
Chuck Low (Morris Kessler)
Frank Dileo (Tuddy Cicero)
Henny Youngman (himself)
Gina Mastrogiacomo (Janice Rossi)
Catherine Scorsese (Tommy’s mother)
Charles Scorsese (Vinnie)
Suzanne Shepherd (Karen’s mother)
Debi Mazar (Sandy)
Margo Winkler (Belle Kessler)
Welker White (Lois Byrd)
Jerry Vale (himself)
Julie Garfield (Mickey Conway)
Christopher Serrone (young Henry)
Elaine Kagan (Henry’s mother)
Beau Starr (Henry’s father)
Kevin Corrigan (Michael Hill)
Michael Imperioli (Spider)
Robbie Vinton (Bobby Vinton)
John Williams (Johnny Roastbeef)
Daniel P. Conte (Dr Dan, Cicero’s ‘50s crew)
Tony Conforti (Tony, Cicero’s ‘50s crew)
Frank Pellegrino (Johnny Dio, Cicero’s ‘50s crew)
Ronald Maccone (Ronnie, Cicero’s ‘50s crew)
Tony Sirico (Tony Stacks, Cicero’s ‘50s crew)
USA 1990
145 mins
Digital
BIG SCREEN CLASSICS
Little Women
Sun 1 Dec 18:10; Mon 16 Dec 14:30; Fri 20 Dec 17:50
My Night with Maud Ma nuit chez Maud
Mon 2 Dev 18:10; Thu 5 Dec 12:20; Tue 17 Dec 20:30
Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence
Tue 3 Dec 20:35; Sat 21 Dec 14:50
When Harry Met Sally
Wed 4 Dec 18:10 + intro by Ruby McGuigan, BFI Programme and Acquisitions; Fri 20 Dec 20:50; Sun 22 Dec 12:15
Torch Song Trilogy
Fri 6 Dec 18:05; Fri 13 Dec 20:30
Female Trouble
Fri 6 Dec 20:50; Wed 18 Dec 20:50; Sun 29 Dec 18:30
Fanny and Alexander Fanny och Alexander
Sat 7 Dec 19:30; Sun 29 Dec 14:15
The City of Lost Children La Cité des enfants perdus
Sun 8 Dec 15:15; Fri 27 Dec 20:45
Tangerine
Mon 9 Dec 20:45; Sat 21 Dec 20:45
Monty Python’s Life of Brian
Wed 11 Dec 18:10 + intro by Justin Johnson, BFI Lead Programmer, Thu 19 Dec 12:30; Sun 22 Dec 18:30
Carol
Thu 12 Dec 12:20; Sat 21 Dec 20:40; Mon 30 Dec 17:50
Eyes Wide Shut
Sat 14 Dec 20:00; Wed 18 Dec 17:40; Sat 28 Dec 17:00
Goodfellas
Sun 15 Dec 17:50; Mon 23 Dec 20:10; Sat 28 Dec 20:15
SIGHT AND SOUND
Never miss an issue with Sight and Sound, the BFI’s internationally renowned film magazine. Subscribe from just £25*
*Price based on a 6-month print subscription (UK only). More info: sightandsoundsubs.bfi.org.uk
BFI SOUTHBANK
Welcome to the home of great film and TV, with three cinemas and a studio, a world-class library, regular exhibitions and a pioneering Mediatheque with 1000s of free titles for you to explore. Browse special-edition merchandise in the BFI Shop.We're also pleased to offer you a unique new space, the BFI Riverfront – with unrivalled riverside views of Waterloo Bridge and beyond, a delicious seasonal menu, plus a stylish balcony bar for cocktails or special events. Come and enjoy a pre-cinema dinner or a drink on the balcony as the sun goes down.
BECOME A BFI MEMBER
Enjoy a great package of film benefits including priority booking at BFI Southbank and BFI Festivals. Join today at bfi.org.uk/join
BFI PLAYER
We are always open online on BFI Player where you can watch the best new, cult & classic cinema on demand. Showcasing hand-picked landmark British and independent titles, films are available to watch in three distinct ways: Subscription, Rentals & Free to view.
See something different today on player.bfi.org.uk
Join the BFI mailing list for regular programme updates. Not yet registered? Create a new account at www.bfi.org.uk/signup
**Programme notes and credits compiled by Sight and Sound and the BFI Documentation Unit
Notes may be edited or abridged
Questions/comments? Contact the Programme Notes team by [email](mailto: